He Believes in Believable Beliefs
Thursday, January 12, 2006 at 11:04AM
Figaro

alitoblank.jpgQuote:  "I think the Constitution is a living thing in the sense that…it sets up a framework of government and a protection of fundamental rights that we have lived under very successfully for 200 years." Supreme Court Nominee Samuel Alito.

Figure of Speech:  antistasis (an TIS ta sis), the repeat that changes meaning.

A Senator asked Alito what he thought of the "living Constitution"— the concept that the Supreme Court's interpretations must adapt to societal change.  Liberals love it, conservatives hate it.

His answer:  "The Constitution is living because we live under it." (Thanks to Slate’s  Dahlia Lithwick for the translation).  An antistasis (Greek for "anti-position") repeats a word while changing its meaning.  Alito uses it to express precisely what he means to say:

Nothing.

Snappy Answer:  "It was living, but I think you just talked it to death."

Article originally appeared on Figures of Speech (http://inpraiseofargument.com/).
See website for complete article licensing information.